Mullica Hill Amish Market - Mullica Hill, New Jersey

Alea B.

Honestly, if I were able to I would've put 6 stars here. I love coming here. The food is always fresh and delicious, and they have a huge variety. The pretzels are always fresh and warm, they have a huge case of donuts. The bathroom is always clean, the place never looks dirty, even when it is packed full of people. There is definitely something here for everyone! The only bad thing, is the parking lot is small, for it's shared with other shops.

Valerie B.

Fresh meats, eye roast was incredible when I cooked it. So fresh! Comparable to grocery store pricing. Lunch meats are always fresh and flavorful. I highly recommend you shop there. Enjoy

Aaron

Wow! What an awesome market this is. I could spend lots of time and $$ here. They have every counter and treat you could ask for. This is the best amish farmers market I've gone to without having to go to PA.

From the chicken shack, I got the $16 beef rib dinner platter. It came with 2 sides as I chose potato wedges and lima beans. The beef rib, tender, beefy, and soooo good. Well worth the price! The lima beans had these chunks of pork in them too and it just elevated them to the next level. I also got a link of kielbasa because they looked so good that I would be kicking myself if I didn't get one. It had a great snap to it, and smoke flavor came through like crazy!

Beilers donuts, I had to get a half dozen, and I was tempted to get a full dozen. They make some of the best donuts in my humble opinion. The varieties are out of this world.

I also got a corned beef rueben wrapped in pretzel dough. This was also fantastic, and they also have different varieties. Not pictured is the refreshing lemonade I bought too. I didn't buy any of the whoopie pies but they looked delicious too.

Edward W.

Love to stop in this place when I’m up in the area and they’re open, but I don’t think I’ll go there on a Saturday again it was mobbed. I went there, hoping to get a rotisserie duck, but they didn’t have any so I just went to the butcher counter and bought a fresh duck and cooked that and it was delicious. Love this place. The food is very high-quality and they’re such a variety there of home-cooked goods.

Est L.

The food was good, but the buffet was small compared to what I expected and I paid the same price as if I had gone to Golden corral which I wasn't expecting being an Amish buffet and normally their prices are reasonable. The market is impressive, but my complaint is if I'm going to pay like the commercial chain restaurants, there needs to be more variety.

Angela

Large bakery section with freshly made pies, cakes, cookies, donuts and more! Get here early because the place is always crowded with customers even on Friday mornings. Nice selection of meats and cold cuts, cheese galore! Seafood section, dine in breakfast and lunch area with a small buffet option. Robust selection of treats and confectioneries. There is a market area for wines red and white. There is also a small farmers market with veggies and fruits and freshly squeezed 100% Juice. Prices are fair as the food your getting is fresh and mostly prepared on site. This is an absolute must-see and try!

Jo-Anis V.

Fantastic place! Everything was so fresh and delicious. It is a long way from home otherwise I'd be there every week!

J B.

So much selection, so many Amish operated businesses. This place is an absolute gem, and the community is so lucky having it in their town... From fresh meats, baked good, and home style cooking, this place is the same it has been for decades.... Always busy, and you know why... They even have a nice restaurant. I only come here for the best donuts in the country.