Surf City Fishery Co - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Address: 902 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008.
Phone: 94948171.

Specialties: Seafood market.
Other points of interest: Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Credit cards.
Opinions: This company has 92 reviews on Google My Business.
Average opinion: 4.4/5.

📌 Location of Surf City Fishery Co

Surf City Fishery Co 902 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008

☎️94948171

⏰ Open Hours of Surf City Fishery Co

Monday: 10 AM–6 PM
Tuesday: 10 AM–6 PM
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10 AM–6 PM
Friday: 10 AM–6 PM
Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
Sunday: 10 AM–6 PM

Surf City Fishery Co

Surf City Fishery Co is a well-established seafood market located at 902 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008. This reputable establishment has garnered a 4.4/5 rating on Google My Business from 92 reviews, testifying to its quality offerings and service. The company specializes in providing a wide variety of fresh seafood, making it a popular destination for both locals and tourists alike.

Specialties: At Surf City Fishery Co, customers can expect to find a reasonably diverse selection of fish and shellfish. The market is particularly known for its superb shellfish options, which include a range of fresh oysters, clams, and shrimp. Additionally, the store offers a selection of other seafood options such as crab, lobster, and various types of fish.

Other points of interest: Surf City Fishery Co is committed to ensuring customer convenience and accessibility. The market provides wheelchair accessible parking, making it easier for all customers to access their goods. Furthermore, the store accepts debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and credit cards, offering multiple payment options for its clientele.

While the seafood market has received mostly positive feedback, some customers have noted that the prices are a bit on the higher side. However, others have emphasized that the quality of the fish makes it worth the extra expense. A few reviews have mentioned that the fish quality can vary, with some customers preferring other establishments on the island. Nevertheless, the majority of reviews praise the market's selection and freshness.

Overall, Surf City Fishery Co is a reliable and reputable seafood market that offers a wide selection of fresh fish and shellfish. Its convenient location, wheelchair accessible parking, and multiple payment options make it an attractive choice for seafood lovers in the area. Though some customers have mentioned higher prices and varying fish quality, the majority of reviews reflect a high level of satisfaction with the market's offerings.

Address: 902 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008

Phone: 94948171

👍 Reviews of Surf City Fishery Co

Surf City Fishery Co - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

David M.

3/5

Reasonable selection of fish. Better selection of shell fish. Prices are a bit steep. Fish quality... Not sure it would be my first choice compared to other places on the island. Downgraded to 3 stars after visiting another. The halibut here looked a bit grey & thin by comparison. Also not sure why they sell wet-packed scallops. Obviously there's a market for the cheaper shellfish, but the taste is so much better with dry-pack (which they also sell for about $5 more per pound -- totally worth it when you understand you're not paying for water injected into the scallops)

Scott M.

2/5

We always buy bulk clams to make clams casino. This was the first time we bought from surf city fishery they were very pleasant on the phone and we decided to make the drive all the way from the south end of the island. The place was a little rundown and clearly had seen better days. The price was a little steep at 60 bucks per hundred but we were initially impressed when they checked every Clam as they were counting them out.
We always soak overnight in freshly collected seawater to allow them to clean themselves. The next day was the first sign of trouble when we found nine dead. Scrubbing and sorting, we found that we were short at 11 and by the time it was time to shuck and prepare the casinos more had died for a total of 32 out of 150 lost or shorted. This was a huge disappointment, we always expect some loss from broken shells or dead Clams, but 21% is ridiculous.

Sunny O.

5/5

Fresh catch of the day with variety you can choose from scallops, steamers, clam, oyster, shrimp and more. I love eat and peel my own foods

M K.

5/5

Mussels were super fresh and made our pasta delicious. Out of two pounds of mussels only a couple of them weren’t viable. Satisfied customer.

Mike B.

5/5

Every year I come to LBI, I have to stop here. They have some of the freshest seafood on the island and the customer service is amazing. Every year I call ahead to see what they got and Marty is always excited to give me the rundown. This year I was specifically looking for cherry stone clams and he explained the history of clams to me so instead of cherry stones, I went with the top necks. I came in and everyone was super pleasant and Marty greeted us with a smile. Give this place a try!

My family travels from PA and VA and this is one place we HAVE to go to. Thanks Marty and his team for the continued years of great service & high quality fish.

Steve C.

5/5

Excellent selection to choose from. I went with the halibut and the guys cut it perfectly for me -- 2 pounds cut it into 5 to 6 ounce portions. The whole family thought it was fresh and delicious.

Richard G.

5/5

Super helpful in setting up my wife's birthday dinner! Fresh lobster, jumbo shrimp, & corn! Even gave me tips for best preparation! Dinner was incredible thanks to the guys here! Drove all the way from Jackson, and the ride was worthwhile!

Courtney B. O.

5/5

They limited how many people are allowed in the store at once. I greatly appreciate efforts like this and will be going there again. Their fish is fresh and delicious as well! We stocked up for several days and are very happy with the quality.